Time Heals but Scars Remain

For reclamation, Missouri trusts MoDNR’s Land Reclamation Program

Medium pond in an open field scattered with wild flowers and grasses, Trees line the background and fluffy scattered clouds fill the sky.

These describe the real-world soil and water conditions that once existed at an abandoned coal mine site in western Missouri until 2024, when the Missouri Department of Natural Resources’ Land Reclamation Program completed the Horn Branch Reclamation Project. You can imagine how hard it would be for plants and animals to survive in such harsh surroundings. 

Graphic with descriptions: Abandoned Strip Pit: A deep, excavated area left behind after strip mining. If not reclaimed, these pits often fill with water and can be hazardous if located near residential areas or roadways. Highwall: A dangerous, unstable vertical rock or earth face left after surface mining operations. Mine Spoils: Waste soil removed during coal mining. The layer of soil that was nearest the coal sits on top of the pile, with topsoil at the bottom. Contaminated runoff from spoil piles can seep into the ground or drain onto surrounding areas.

From the early 1950s until 1972, the Peabody Coal Company mined approximately 1,200 acres of coal east of Germantown and north of Montrose in Henry County. Most of the surface mining, a method commonly used when coal deposits are located close to the surface, took place when there was little to no regulation requiring a company to protect the environment or reclaim the land back to productive use. 

Surface mining uses machines to remove the top layers of soil to expose the coal layer, or seam, underneath. As a result, a tributary to Horn Branch was directly impacted and the area was left with rugged terrain, making it difficult to traverse. 

The hazards left behind included multiple acid ponds that would not support fish or aquatic populations, and extremely acidic soils that would not support plant life for at least 60 to 70 years after mining ceased.

One of the Land Reclamation Program’s missions is to reclaim abandoned coal mines to protect public health and the environment. The program’s main goal for the Horn Branch Reclamation Project was to return 107 acres of surface-mined land back to productive acreage for private landowners. 

The project’s higher-priority health and safety features included reclamation of 1,770 feet of dangerous highwalls, four polluted water bodies, 20 acres of spoil area and 23 acres of dangerous piles and embankments. Large and dangerous erosion areas were also stabilized by adding a better stand of perennial vegetation and eliminating some acid-producing barren areas.

One of the biggest environmental concerns for the Horn Branch project was sulfuric acid. Since no regulations were in place at the time of mining, and to remove and stockpile topsoil for later reclamation, all the site’s original topsoil was buried deep while the acidic soil layer closest to a coal seam ended up on the surface and exposed to the elements. 

Missouri coal burns hotter than other types under certain conditions, and it is found in seams that contain more sulfur and pyrite content. In the presence of water and oxygen, the high sulfur mining waste material, called spoil, produced sulfuric acid that eroded into strip pits and tributaries that flowed to Horn Branch. Water and soil samples taken before the reclamation project were in the highly acidic 2.5 to 3.3 pH range, compared to neutral 7 pH. The samples also yielded higher iron, sulfate, aluminum and manganese levels than a healthy stream.

Brent Willeford, the department’s in-house abandoned mine land engineer at the time, designed the project with the help of project managers and a unit chief. The most challenging part was that 1,228 acres drained through the project area in a stair-step fashion due to abandoned strip pits and many easily eroded earthen dams, which sent sediments and acidic mine drainage downstream. 

Large earth-moving equipment excavated approximately 480,000 cubic yards of acidic spoils to achieve gentle slopes and promote positive drainage. To successfully neutralize the acidity, more than 9,500 tons of agricultural lime were trucked in along with 6,420 pounds of nitrogen, 16,050 pounds of phosphorus and 21,400 pounds of potassium. Most of the project area was seeded with native cool-season grasses and legumes, while 13 acres were seeded with native warm-season grasses and legumes to be used as a wildlife area.

The reclamation project’s cost totaled nearly $2.3 million, with funding provided by a federal grant from the Abandoned Coal Mine Reclamation Fund. This fund is generated by collecting a fee on every ton of coal produced in the United States. The money is then distributed to states to clean up coal mine lands worked prior to the Surface Mining and Control Act of 1977.  

Missouri’s distribution is calculated by using the current and historical coal production tonnages in the state, which together yield an annual grant amount of $2.9 million.

The Land Reclamation Program uses this grant funding to reclaim sites in priority order. The abandoned mine lands posing the greatest threat to public health and safety come first, followed by lower safety risks and then environmental concerns. Eligible lands that have high priority safety features with environmental scars from mining on the same acreage, or nearby, are addressed simultaneously to maximize the funding impact.

The Horn Branch Reclamation Project is just one example of the department’s many successes in reclaiming Missouri’s abandoned mine lands.

Nonetheless, one question remains: Does time heal all wounds? On this project, with a little help from the Abandoned Mine Land Unit, we certainly think this part of Henry County is on the right track to once again being a safe and healthy reflection of Missouri’s natural beauty.

For more information about land reclamation in Missouri, visit the Missouri Geological Survey’s Land Reclamation Program webpage.

  • A portrait of Austin Rehagen

    Austin Rehagen is the abandoned mine lands unit chief with the Missouri Department of Natural Resources’ Land Reclamation Program.

    View all posts